Skip to content
Mainepedia
Picnic tables above the folded ledge at Two Lights in Cape Elizabeth, July 2012. The twin lighthouses that give the point its name stand further along Two Lights Road, outside the state park, and neither is open to the public.
Back to Best Of

Best Lobster Shacks in Maine 2026: Top Lobster Rolls & Seafood

Maine's best lobster shacks ranked: Red's Eats, Five Islands, McLoons, and more. Where to find the best lobster rolls, prices, what to expect, and insider tips.

Picnic tables above the folded ledge at Two Lights in Cape Elizabeth, July 2012. The twin lighthouses that give the point its name stand further along Two Lights Road, outside the state park, and neither is open to the public. Photo by Dirk Ingo Franke via source, CC BY 3.0. Resized for this page.
1

Red's Eats

The most famous lobster roll in the world. Expect a long line, but the pile of unadulterated meat is legendary.

2

Five Islands Lobster Co.

Located on a working wharf overlooking a stunning harbor. The views are as good as the food. No fillers, just fresh catch.

3

McLoons Lobster Shack

A hidden gem located on a small island accessed by a causeway. A red cottage serving incredibly fresh lobster in a postcard setting.

4

The Clam Shack

Famous for serving their lobster roll on a round hamburger bun with both butter and mayo. A consistent award winner.

5

Waterman's Beach Lobster

A James Beard award winner known for its simplicity and seaside picnic tables. (Note: Check seasonal hours).

6

Thurston's Lobster Pound

Overlooking a busy harbor, Thurston's steams lobsters in a unique screened-in room. A classic Acadia experience.

There is no more quintessential Maine dining experience than a lobster shack. These aren’t white-tablecloth establishments; they are often simple shacks on a pier, with picnic tables, paper plates, and a view of the lobster boats that caught your lunch.

The Experience

A true lobster shack experience involves a few key elements:

  1. The Wait: The best places have lines. It’s part of the ritual.
  2. The View: You should be able to smell the salt air.
  3. BYOB: Many shacks don’t serve alcohol but allow you to bring your own cooler of local beer or wine.
  4. No Frills: Don’t expect table service. You order at the window, grab your number, and wait for the call.

Pick Your Style

Purists insist on a “naked” roll, just lobster meat and a little butter. Others prefer the light toss of mayo. At a shack, you can usually get it your way, along with steamers (clams), corn on the cob, and a slice of blueberry pie.

Common Questions

Where is the best lobster roll in Maine?

Red's Eats in Wiscasset is often cited as having Maine's best lobster roll, famous for its massive pile of unadulterated meat. Five Islands Lobster Co. and McLoons are close runners-up.

How much is a lobster roll in Maine?

Lobster is sold at market rate and the price moves week to week, which is exactly why shacks post a board rather than printing a menu price. The bands previously given here were not sourced from any operator. Red's Eats charges a premium and serves an enormous portion, a full pound of claw and tail meat with no filler, which is the reason for the queue and for the price.

What's the difference between Maine and Connecticut style lobster rolls?

Maine-style lobster rolls are served cold with mayonnaise on a split-top bun. Connecticut-style are served warm with drawn butter. Most Maine shacks serve Maine-style, but many offer both options.

Do Maine lobster shacks take reservations?

No, lobster shacks are casual order-at-the-window operations. Expect to wait in line at popular spots like Red's Eats (sometimes 30-60 minutes in summer). Bring BYOB drinks and enjoy the wait.

Explore More of Maine

Looking for more inspiration? Browse our full directory of towns or explore by region.

Browse All Towns View Regions